February 5, 2013 -- Updated
- In this winter of his disinterment, we pause to ponder if Richard III, the last Plantaganet king of England, was a victim of a pen poisoned by history controlled by his Tudor successors.
As archeologists sort through a skull and bones found an English parking lot and
with DNA tests confirming the remains were Richard's, there is a call
for a re-examination of his legacy -- which has mostly been shaped by
Shakespeare's play Richard III.
Shakespeare's Richard III
is a "rudely stamp'd," "deformed, unfinish'd" villain who ordered the
deaths of anyone who stood between him and the throne, including his two
young nephews.
The remains of King Richard III
Tracking down Richard III's remains
The king in the parking lot
Richard III: The mystery of the king and the car parking loy "So wise so young, they
say, do never live long," Richard III says in a sinister aside as he
dispatches Crown Prince Edward, 12, and brother Richard, 9, to their
deaths in the Tower of London.
"Off with his head!" Richard shouts in Act III, sending Lord Hastings to the chopping block.
Shakespeare's story
evolved from a history penned by Sir Thomas More more than two decades
after Richard died in the Battle of Bosworth in 1485. It was the last
fight in the War of the Roses, which ended with the ascension of Henry
VII and the Tudors.
The Tudors, who
controlled More's world, had a vested interest in disparaging Richard
and bolstering their family's claim to the throne.
The Richard III Society
has "been working since 1924 to secure a more balanced assessment of the
king and to support research into his life and times," according to the
society's website.
The recent excavation of
the burial site that once was a church "has raised the king's profile
and provided us with new opportunities to make the case for 'Good King
Richard,'" the society said.
Richard III Society Chairman Dr. Phil Stone that a "cursory reading of the known facts will show that the Tudor
representation of Richard III, especially that in Shakespeare's well
known play, just doesn't stand up."
As Queen Elizabeth advised Richard III in Shakespeare's Act VI: "An honest tale speeds best, being plainly told."
"It would make such a
difference if people would start to look into the history of this much
maligned monarch without the old prejudices," Stone wrote. "Perhaps,
then, they will see past the myth and innuendo that has blackened his
name and find the truth."
You may not find a
saint, "but neither was he a criminal," Stone said. "All but one of the
so-called crimes laid at his door can be refuted by the facts." That
crime was the killing of the rival nephews, known in history as the
"Princes in the Tower," he said.
And there are other suspects, including Henry VII or other Tudors.
Radiocarbon dating,
radiological evidence, DNA and bone analysis and archaeological result
confirmed the remains found under the parking lot, the former site of
Grey Friars church, were those of Richard III, researchers at University
of Leicester told reporters Monday.
Clues coaxed from the
skeleton may shed "a new light" on the physical description of Richard
III as a humpbacked man with a "withered arm," which was used to support
history's evil image of him, Professor Lin Foxhall, head of the
University of Leicester's School of Archaeology and Ancient History,
said.
"Our archaeological
research does not tell us anything about the character of Richard III,
and of course his physical condition and appearance were not a
manifestation of his character, Foxhall said. Comparing the new
archeological finds to history texts "could end up re-writing a little
bit of history in a big way."
One immediate discovery is that his skeleton does not have a "withered arm" as depicted by Shakespeare, the researchers said.
While not humpbacked, he did suffer from "severe scoliosis" that appeared to start around the time of puberty, they said.
The confirmation of
Richard's remains may make no difference in the royal world, but it does
mean the king will finally get a proper burial. His body will be
reinterred in the Leicester Cathedral early next year.
"A hearse, a hearse, my kingdom for a hearse," more than a few punsters tweeted upon that news.
The rehabilitation of
Richard III moves ahead Tuesday when the Richard III Society unveils a
"new" face for their hero based on facial reconstruction using the
newly-found skull.
To poach a phrase from Hamlet's mouth, spoken as he held the jester Yorick's skull: Alas, poor Richard!
Read more: updatallnews
No comments:
Post a Comment